Unraveling the Mystery of a 50-Year-Old Double Homicide: A Cold Case Cracked through Forensic Science and Genealogy
In the quiet town of Ledyard, Connecticut, half a century ago, the skeletal remains of two individuals were discovered in a shallow grave. It was December 31, 1970, and the chilling scene marked the beginning of an intricate investigation that would span over five decades.
The first victim, identified as Linda Sue Childers, was one of two people who fell victim to a brutal double homicide. According to the Connecticut State Police, her remains were unearthed in 1974, over three-and-a-half years after she and her companion had been mercilessly taken from their lives.
However, for nearly five decades, Linda’s identity remained a mystery. Her case baffled investigators due to the use of an unverified alias that hindered the process of identifying her. Consequently, the perpetrators responsible for the heinous crimes went unidentified as well.
Investigations revealed that two men, Richard DeFreitas and Donald Brant, were arrested and convicted for the crime shortly after the bodies were discovered. Tragically, both of these individuals are now deceased, leaving many questions unanswered.
Linda’s remains were found with clothing and personal belongings that provided a glimpse into her past. These items included a tan leather “wet look” vest, a gold or tan sweater, a brown tweed skirt, and a pair of brown granny boots. Additionally, she was wearing a pendant and rings that bore the initials J.H.S.N., I.L.N., and the date 1917.
To shed light on this enigmatic case, her case data, dental X-rays, and description were uploaded to the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System in 2011. Her data was also added to the Combined DNA Index System in 2012.
In July 2022, a breakthrough occurred as DNA samples were sent to a private genetic genealogy company collaborating with the state. A meticulous investigation ensued, and in January 2024, Linda’s sister was identified through DNA results. Months later, her daughter provided the definitive confirmation of Linda’s identity in February 2024.
Conversations with the family verified Linda’s whereabouts throughout the years leading up to her disappearance, providing a sense of resolution for those close to her. The other victim was previously identified as Gustavous Lee Carmichael, a notorious serial bank robber with a history of escaping federal custody.
Advancements in forensic science technology and the innovative use of forensic investigative genetic genealogy have significantly contributed to solving cases like Linda’s. By combining DNA analysis with traditional genealogy research, investigators can unlock the secrets of the past and bring closure to families seeking answers.
